Filters
Apple Pie Caramel Apple
Sale priceFrom $24.99
Brownie Points Bundle
Sale price$54.99
Regular price$64.99
Caramel and Chocolate Dipped Brownie Pops - 6 Pack
Sale price$29.99
Caramel and Chocolate Dipped Oreos - 12 Pack
Sale price$23.99
Caramel Apple Bundle - Mix and Match 4
Sale price$44.99
Regular price$99.96
Caramel Chocolate Pretzel Rods - 10 Pack
Sale price$39.99
Caramel Dipped Cinnamon Bears - 4 Pack
Sale price$19.99
Chocolate Caramel Pouch 8oz
Sale price$9.99
Chocolate Lovers Bundle
Sale price$59.99
Regular price$115.85
Deluxe Assorted Caramels Box
Sale price$24.99
Factory Tour Bundle
Sale price$54.99
Regular price$77.88
Fan Favorites Bundle
Sale price$79.99
Regular price$94.99
Fans Favorite
Sale price$0.00
Homemade Reese's Caramel Apple
Sale priceFrom $24.99
Homemade Toffee Caramel Apple
Sale priceFrom $24.99
Honey Caramel Pouch 8oz
Sale price$9.99
Huckleberry Caramel Pouch 8oz
Sale price$9.99
Oreo Caramel Apple
Sale priceFrom $24.99
Pecan Turtle Caramel Apple
Sale priceFrom $24.99
Salted Caramel Rice Krispies - 10 pack
Sale price$29.99
Salted Pretzel Caramel Apple
Sale priceFrom $24.99
Sea Salt Caramel Pouch 8oz
Sale price$9.99
Sea Salt Chocolate Covered Caramel
Sale price$7.99
Select 3 Items
Sale price$29.90
ShipInsure Package Protection
Sale priceFrom $0.98
Signature Caramel Pouch 8oz
Sale price$9.99
Snickers Caramel Apple
Sale priceFrom $24.99
So Much to Love Gift Box
Sale price$74.99
Regular price$110.88
Sweet & Simple Gift Box
Sale price$49.99
Regular price$86.99
Toasted Almond Caramel Apple
Sale priceFrom $24.99